The National Weather Service office in Albuquerque notes that counties in central New Mexico see damaging hail at least a couple of times a year, and the July 30, 2018 storm dropped ping-pong-ball hail across the metro. Wind off the Sandias and spring fronts do the rest. If you’ve been through one of those, here is how a roof claim actually works — without the sales pitch.
Step 1: Find out if you have damage before you file
Hail bruises shingles. It knocks granules loose, cracks the mat underneath, and leaves soft spots that leak months later — but from the driveway the roof often looks fine. Wind creases and lifts shingles along the edges and ridges, breaks the seal strip, and tears flat-roof membranes at the seams.
Get a free, on-roof inspection with a photo report first. A good inspection chalks a 10×10 test square on each slope and counts hits, the same way adjusters do. It also checks soft metals — vents, flashing, swamp cooler panels, gutters — because dents there prove hail size and direction. Only after you know what’s up there should you decide whether to open a claim; a claim with no damage is a mark on your record for nothing.
Step 2: File the claim and schedule the adjuster
You, the policyholder, file the claim — by phone or through your carrier’s app. Have the date of the storm, the inspection photos and the roofer’s report ready. The carrier assigns an adjuster and schedules a visit.
Ask your roofer to meet the adjuster on the roof. Zenith does this at no charge. The adjuster sees a lot of roofs quickly; a roofer who has already walked yours can point out every slope with hits, the dented vents, the cracked tile, the lifted membrane seam. Damage that isn’t pointed out doesn’t get paid.
Step 3: Understand how the claim is paid
Most homeowner policies pay roof claims like this:
- Replacement cost value (RCV) is what it costs to replace the damaged roof today.
- Depreciation is subtracted for the roof’s age and condition. The carrier pays the actual cash value (ACV) — RCV minus depreciation minus your deductible — as a first check.
- If your policy is an RCV policy, the depreciation is recoverable: once the roof is replaced and the final invoice is submitted, the carrier releases the second check.
Two things to check in your policy before a storm, not after. Some policies now cover roofs on an ACV-only basis (depreciation is not recoverable), especially for older roofs. And some carriers have moved to a percentage wind/hail deductible (for example 1–2% of the dwelling coverage) instead of a flat dollar amount, which can be several thousand dollars.
Step 4: Review the scope and ask for a supplement if it’s short
The adjuster’s estimate is a line-item scope: squares of shingle, underlayment, flashing, drip edge, vents, disposal. Compare it with your roofer’s inspection. It’s common for the first scope to miss things — the second layer that has to come off, code-required ice-and-water membrane, a detached garage, gutters — and the normal process is to submit a supplement with photos and documentation. That’s a routine part of the job, not an argument.
Step 5: Build, then close the claim
Materials and colors are chosen, the permit is pulled, and most homes are re-roofed in one to two days. Completion photos and the final invoice go to the carrier to release recoverable depreciation. Your deductible is paid to the roofer as part of the final invoice.
The mistakes that cost people money
Signing on the hood of a truck after a storm. Storm chasers roll into the metro after every hail event. Check the New Mexico contractor license, look for a local address and real reviews, and never sign a contract you haven’t read.
“We’ll waive your deductible.” No one can. A contractor who offers to eat your deductible is either padding the invoice to the insurer (fraud) or cutting the job to make up the difference. Walk away.
Signing an assignment of benefits without understanding it. Some documents hand control of your claim and its payments to the contractor. You can authorize a roofer to talk to your carrier without signing over the claim.
Waiting. Hail hits get harder to attribute to a specific storm as the roof weathers, and leaks that start six months later become “maintenance” in the adjuster’s eyes. Inspect early.
If you’re not sure whether what happened to your roof is a claim, start with the free inspection — you get the photo report either way, and you can send it straight to your insurer. See hail & storm damage claims.