Most roofs don’t fail all at once. They give notice for a year or two first — if you know what to look for. Here is the checklist we use, split into what you can see from the ground, what shows up inside the house, and what only shows up on the roof.
From the ground
1. Granules in the gutters or at the downspouts. Shingles shed their protective granules as they age. A handful of sand-like grit after a storm is normal on a new roof; a steady accumulation on an older one means the asphalt underneath is now exposed to the sun.
2. Curling, cupping or clawing shingles. Edges turning up (curling) or the middle lifting (clawing) means the shingle has dried out and shrunk. Those shingles no longer seal to each other and will go in the next wind event.
3. Bald or dark patches. Areas where the granules are gone show as darker, shinier patches, usually on the south- and west-facing slopes that take the most sun.
4. Cracked, split or missing shingles. Thermal cycling cracks brittle shingles; wind takes the ones whose seal strip has failed.
5. Sagging roofline. A dip in the ridge or a slope that looks wavy means the decking or framing beneath it has been wet. This one is urgent.
6. Moss, algae or debris buildup in valleys. Less common in the desert, but shaded valleys in the East Mountains and under big cottonwoods in the Valley hold moisture and debris that keep the roof wet.
7. Flat roof: ponding, blisters and alligatoring. Water still standing two days after rain, bubbles in the surface, or a cracked, scaly pattern in an old coating all mean the roof is aging under water or UV.
8. Stucco cracks along the parapet. On pueblo-style homes, horizontal cracks or staining at the top of the wall where it meets the roof are a sign the parapet joint has opened.
Inside the house
9. Water stains on ceilings or walls — especially ones that grow after monsoon storms. Note where they are; a stain under a vent or chimney is often a flashing repair, while stains scattered across a ceiling point to a roof that is done.
10. Daylight through the roof boards. Go into the attic on a bright day with the lights off. Any pinpoints of light are holes.
11. Soft or stained decking in the attic. Dark stains on the underside of the roof deck, or boards that feel spongy, mean water has been getting through long enough to soak the wood.
12. Rising cooling bills. A roof that has lost its reflective surface, or an attic with failed ventilation, pushes more heat into the house. It’s not proof by itself, but it’s a reason to look.
Usually a repair, not a replacement
- A leak at one penetration — a cracked rubber pipe boot, a rusted vent, a skylight curb — is a one-day repair when the rest of the roof is sound.
- Lifted or missing shingles after one wind event, on a roof that is otherwise pliable and holding granules.
- A failed canale or scupper on a flat roof: replace the drain, fix the ponding behind it, and the roof keeps going.
- One cracked or slid tile on a tile roof — a matched replacement, not a new roof.
The one you can’t see: hail
A roof that has taken a hail storm can look perfectly normal from the ground. The damage — bruises in the shingle mat, cracked tile, punctured membrane, dented vents — shows up on the roof and in the test square. If your neighborhood has had hail or a big wind event, that roof is worth an inspection even if it isn’t leaking, because storm damage may be covered by your homeowner’s insurance where ordinary aging never is. Our hail claim guide explains how that works.
If you ticked several boxes above, the roof planner helps you share your roof details and request an inspection for a written proposal. If you ticked one or two, start with a free inspection — repair first is the honest answer more often than people expect.