Most pitched roofs in the Albuquerque metro are asphalt shingle. Head into the East Mountains and you see far more metal. Both are good roofs. They suit different houses and different owners.
Lifespan
In our climate, architectural shingles realistically last 25 to 30 years and metal lasts 40 to 60. If you plan to stay in the home for decades, one metal roof can replace two shingle roofs.
Weather
Hail. Hail bruises shingles and knocks off granules, which shortens their life. Hail dents metal, especially softer panels, but dents seldom leak.
Wind. Properly fastened standing seam metal holds up very well in high wind. Shingles depend on their seal strips, and a creased shingle is a damaged shingle.
Snow. Metal sheds snow. That is why it dominates in Tijeras, Cedar Crest and Sandia Park. Snow guards keep it from sliding off in sheets over doors and walkways.
Sun and fire. Reflective metal finishes lower cooling load, and metal is non-combustible, which matters for homes near piñon and juniper.
Cost
Metal costs more than shingle, and standing seam costs more than exposed-fastener panel. We price metal after an on-roof inspection because panel layout, trim and the details where metal meets stucco walls drive the number. A full shingle replacement starts lower; our cost guide explains what moves it.
Noise
On a house with solid decking, underlayment and attic insulation, rain on metal is not much louder than on shingles. Barns and open patios are where metal is loud.
Looks and rules
Metal suits ranch, mountain and territorial styles. Some HOAs restrict it, so check your covenants first.
Solar
Standing seam is one of the best roofs for solar because mounts clamp to the seams with no holes. If solar is in your plans, that is a point for metal.
Not all metal roofs are the same
Standing seam panels lock together along raised seams, and the fasteners are hidden underneath. With no screws through the surface, there is nothing to back out or leak as the roof expands and contracts every day. This is the system most people picture on a house.
Exposed-fastener panels are screwed through the face with rubber-washered screws. They cost less and go on faster, which is why they cover so many barns and shops. The washers dry out in the sun over time, so the screws need to be checked and replaced as the roof ages.
Thickness and finish matter too. Residential panels are commonly 24 or 26 gauge, and the lower number is the thicker steel, which resists denting better. Finish quality shows up years later: better paint systems hold their color and resist chalking far longer in high-altitude sun, so ask what finish and what finish warranty come with the panel.
Under any metal roof, the underlayment should be a high-temperature product. Metal gets hot enough to break down ordinary felt.
How to decide
Choose shingles if budget is the priority or you may sell within ten years. Choose metal if you are staying, you live with snow and wind, or you never want to re-roof again. We install both: see shingle and metal, or start with a free inspection.