Evaporative coolers work well in dry air, which is why so many New Mexico roofs carry one. They are also a box of water sitting on a hole in your roof. When a homeowner calls about a leak in July with no rain in the forecast, the cooler is the first place to look.
Where the water comes from
The pan and float valve. The float shuts the water off when the pan is full. When it sticks or the seat wears out, the pan overflows. If the overflow tube is plugged or missing, the water runs down the stand and onto the roof for as long as the cooler is on.
The water line. The small supply line runs across the roof in full sun. Plastic line gets brittle and splits; copper kinks and pinholes. A line left pressurized over winter can freeze and crack, then leak from the first warm day.
A rusted pan. Mineral-heavy water eats the bottom of a steel cooler from the inside. A pan can look fine from the side and be leaking through the bottom into the duct.
The duct opening. The duct drops through the roof into the ceiling. On a flat roof it should sit on a raised, flashed curb. On a pitched roof it needs a flashed roof jack. Many were sealed with roof cement that has since cracked.
The stand legs. Every leg is a fastener through the roof. Legs set directly on a membrane or shingles, without pads or flashing, wear through it.
What a proper repair looks like
First find out whether the cooler or the roof is leaking. Shut the water off for a few days and watch the stain; if it stops growing, the cooler is the source. Cooler-side fixes are cheap: a new float valve, line, overflow fitting or pads.
Roof-side fixes should not be smeared on. On a flat roof that means a curb with membrane flashing turned up and terminated, and legs on protective pads. On a pitched roof it means a properly flashed jack tied into the shingles. If the decking around the cooler is soft, it has to be cut out and replaced. Wet wood under a patch keeps rotting.
Seasonal checklist
- Spring start-up: new pads, clean the pan, check the float and overflow, inspect the line, and look at the flashing before you turn the water on.
- Mid-summer: look for water on the roof around the stand and white mineral trails running away from the unit.
- Fall shut-down: drain the pan and the line, disconnect the supply, and cover the unit. A drained line cannot freeze and split.
Converting to refrigerated air
When the cooler comes off, the opening should be framed in, decked and roofed to match the surrounding roof. A sheet-metal cap screwed over the hole is a future leak. If the new condenser or package unit is going on the roof, it needs its own curb or stand, flashed properly, and the roof under it should have enough life left to justify the install.
If your roof is within a few years of replacement, plan the conversion and the re-roof together. It costs less to do the roof once.
When to call for an inspection
Soft spots near the cooler, staining that keeps coming back, or a stand that rocks when you push on it all deserve a look. We inspect for free, photograph the cooler flashing and the decking around it, and tell you whether it needs a part from the hardware store, a roof repair, or a bigger plan.