Materials · 3 min read

Tile roof leaking? Why the underlayment fails before the tile

Concrete and clay tile can last 50 years, but the underlayment beneath it does not. How to tell when it is worn out and what a lift-and-relay involves.

Tile roofs are common in Rio Rancho and in newer stucco subdivisions on the Westside. Owners are often surprised when a 25-year-old tile roof leaks, because the tile still looks perfect. The tile usually is fine. The problem is under it.

How a tile roof works

Tile overlaps like scales and sheds most of the rain, but wind-driven water gets under it, especially at valleys, ridges and edges. That water lands on the underlayment, a waterproof sheet over the roof deck, and runs down to the eave. The underlayment is the real roof. The tile is its sunshade and armor.

Why underlayment wears out

Older tile roofs were often installed over ordinary felt. Decades of heat under the tile dry the felt out until it cracks and tears. Debris in the valleys holds water against it. Where a tile has slipped or broken, the sun reaches the felt directly and finishes it off in a season or two.

Signs to watch for

  • Ceiling stains after wind-driven rain, with no broken tile in sight
  • Slipped, cracked or missing tiles
  • Sagging or debris-packed valleys
  • Brittle, torn felt visible at the eaves
  • Mortar at ridges and hips cracking or falling out

What a lift-and-relay includes

  1. The tile is removed and stacked.
  2. Old underlayment, battens and flashing come off, and the deck is inspected and repaired.
  3. New high-temperature underlayment and new flashing go on.
  4. The original tile is reinstalled, with broken pieces replaced by matching ones.

You keep the look of the roof and get a new waterproof layer underneath.

Repair or full relay

One leak in an otherwise healthy roof can be repaired section by section. When the underlayment is brittle across the whole roof, patching chases leaks from one spot to the next, and a full relay is the better use of money.

Concrete or clay, and what that changes

Most tile on newer Albuquerque and Rio Rancho homes is concrete. It is heavy and durable, and its surface color can fade or wear with decades of sun while the tile itself stays sound. Clay tile holds its color and is more brittle, so it breaks more easily underfoot. Either one can be lifted and relaid, but clay usually means a higher count of replacement pieces.

Matching matters. Manufacturers change and discontinue profiles, and a tile that looks close from the ground may not lock into its neighbors. A good crew pulls sound originals from less visible slopes to keep the front of the house uniform and puts the closest available match where it shows least.

Questions to ask before a relay

  • What underlayment are you installing, and is it rated for high temperatures?
  • Are the valley and wall flashings replaced or reused?
  • How do you handle broken tile, and is a breakage allowance in the price?
  • Will bird stops or eave closures be installed to keep nests and debris out from under the first course?

Storm damage

Hail cracks tile. If a storm broke tile across your roof, that may be an insurance claim. See how a hail claim works.

We inspect tile roofs for free and photograph the underlayment where we can see it. More on our tile roofing page.

See your own roof measured. Type your address — explore an aerial roof measurement and request a free inspection. Your written price follows the inspection.
Start my roof plan
FAQ

Questions about this topic

Can I just replace the broken tiles?

If the underlayment is still sound, yes. Broken tiles should be replaced promptly, because sun on exposed underlayment destroys it quickly.

Is it safe to walk on a tile roof?

Not without knowing where to step. Tile breaks under weight in the wrong spot, so leave it to someone who works on tile.